marlowe1: (Default)
8. The Walking Dead vol 31: The Rotton Core by Robert Kirkman, Charlie Adlard, etc. - Just saw a meme that asked "When did you stop with the Walking Dead?" and that does seem to be a universal experience. No show on television had so much potential and so much disappointment. I'm going to repeat what I probably said in 2019 which is that for me The Walking Dead is great as soon as Negan shows up and loses its charm as soon as Negan gets written out. I'm not sure if they are keeping him around in the show but I didn't see much of him. I have no clue where I stopped. I don't think that I even got to the Whisperers on the show.

But as far as the comic - same damn thing. Write out Negan because he really doesn't have much to do. He's had his redemption arc going from villain to anti-hero to useful leader to isolated after saving everyone from the whisperers. And then we get the final boss - Some woman who smiles too much.

So here we are, in the volume before the volume with issue 193 where Kirkman shocked everyone by just fucking ending the whole story. And it makes sense that it's ending here because the overarching plot is the rebuilding of society. So readers have followed Rick and the rest of the characters from isolated camps to a farm to a prison to a suburban community to a confederacy of different communities, strengthened by fighting the Saviors who were the both the main antagonists and the most advanced post-zombie social order. After the Whisperers who were an interesting side quest as people who decided to live among the zombies (I wonder where the comic would have gone if the whisperers turned out to be zombies that had recovered their faculties) we get an entire city full of people who held off the zombies and live life as if nothing has changed.

And this is where it feels rushed. Kirkman was definitely building towards this ending, but he seems to be bored with the comic. Michonne going back to her law career and reuniting with her daughter is interesting but mostly this is a repetition of the usual tropes. One member of the group really loves the new community that they just found. Another member is severely distrustful. Rick is somewhere in the middle but at the end he figures out that something is wrong. The whole social order is built on everyone getting the exact same roles they had before the zombies. The leader seems ok but there are clues that not all is well.

Also the cops beat people to death and no one is happy except for the survivors.

So this one ends with Darryl acting like he wants to overthrow everything and Rick shooting him. And then Rick feeling like he did the wrong thing.

I spent most of this one trying to remember if Rick advanced the Broken Window theory of law enforcement. And when he did it. It actually makes sense that Rick would buy into that horseshit but I forgot the context.

Regardless, I have the last collected Walking Dead from the library. I wonder if it will be as tedious as these last few post-Negan collections or if Kirkman will get a little more energy from knowing that he's ending it.
marlowe1: (Maggie)
12. Mob Psycho 100 book 1 by One - This was recommended because it's a cartoon now and it might be on Netflix so I'm going to check it out. I suspect this will make up the first two episodes as it gives us the character of Shigeo or Mob and fleshes out his world as the assistant to a bogus exorcist with the twist that he actually has psychic powers. Then we have two stories where Mob is forced to interact with people. Those are the more interesting ones because they reminded me that I really need to research autism spectrum since I think I'm guilty of learning about autism in a passive way of "I think I got it" where I know that Autism Speaks is terrible, vaccines don't cause it, many less extreme cases get chalked up as social awkwardness, creepy assholes claim to have it, I think that some of my friends have it but I don't know, something about not getting social cues automatically but being able to train themselves to recognize social cues and the robot boy from AI being a pretty good metaphor for autism (at least according to an article on The Dissolve when that site was viable).

So Shigeo has two major stories. First he is being induced to join an after school group, but he doesn't really want to do it. He even tries to get his boss to get him out of it. Eventually he joins the other group of jocks because that seems better for actually improving his lot in school. The major story, however, is about Shigeo getting involved in a cult that is based on everyone smiling and laughing. They are forced by each other to smile and laugh.

This is where the autism really kicks in (as far as I know from my holy fuck I got to research this) as everyone else is highly influenced by the smiling and laughing part of the cult. Even the people who were originally suspicious of the cult are sucked into it. Only Mob is unmoved. In fact, he doesn't even understand why he's supposed to be moved. He gets that other people are making the faces, but it doesn't really work with him. In fact, it all just makes him more uncomfortable. And then when the counter at the edge of the page gets to 100% he destroys everything.

I think that means that the author is placing autism in the context of a super power. Not that autism is a super power, but that the super powers resemble autism - I think. I might be reading this in the best way possible because I think that I like it and I don't want to get too enmeshed in the "disabilities = magic" debate. I think this version does fall on the decent side of that line, but I don't have autism so I think I should definitely listen to people who are more affected by autism more.

13. The Walking Dead Compedium one by Robert Kirkman and artists - HOLY SHIT! They killed Lori by shooting her through the baby. That's just fucking evil. I read that story before but this is my attempt to just catch up on all the Walking Dead because I'm hooked now, more than I was when I was reading random comics that I picked up and watching most of the episodes but I don't think that the death of Lori was quite as devastating when I read it as a fairly short comic story ending with Lori's death. As something that happened at the end of a collection of 49 issues, it was fucking evil. Because even though I didn't like Lori as a character, I got to know her more over the long story and what she meant.

I think that Lori for all of her nasty decisions and anger was a symbol of the hope that things could get better. Babies are pretty symbolic especially in zombie books but really symbolic in The Walking Dead which is an attempt to truly delve into the collapse of society that comes with zombie movies and does it by skipping over most of the zombie movie plots (except for 28 Days Later which pulled the same coma trick) and going straight to the ending where most people are dead. The army is useless and the zombies are just part of what is going on now. Hell, most of the story line comic books had the same blurb on the back cover which came down to a libertarian fantasy of the world falling apart and no one having to pay taxes or expecting good roads.

So I read the original huge arc that ends with the Governor and Lori is just fucking dead. There are a lot of deaths on Walking Dead and it's kind of interesting to see that Carol is just gone in the comic. Like she just gets very sad and suicidal and lets a zombie bite her. On the other hand, Sophie is still alive according to the Walking Dead wiki. But the differences between source material and adaptation is a discussion that Game of Thrones is practically a cottage industry.

I guess what I'm trying to say is that I see a lot of the same faults with the book as the show - Rick is too much the focal point, minority characters die faster, don't get too attached. I also think that it's more interesting now that we see where its going with the ways that people get together and put society together. In this case, the Governor is the first attempt to show that there is a bigger world out there beyond Rick and the survivalists outside Atlanta and he's fucking awful. Negan on the other hand is much more nuanced - more evil than the Governor, but also more beneficial to the social order as a whole. Governor is a shitty warlord who is stopped by his own hubris. Negan is practically the Chin Dynasty, nasty but bringing everyone together.

Still I am reading this book and this book is the foundation of the series where Rick and friends are trying to just survive and find safety. In that early part of the series, a prison makes sense. Later on it would be a terrible base.

Profile

marlowe1: (Default)
Tim Lieder

December 2023

S M T W T F S
     1 2
345 6789
1011 1213141516
171819 20 212223
24 2526 27 282930
31      

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 8th, 2025 10:55 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios